A handbook on writing argumentative and interpretative essays

Homosexual citizens in our society must therefore be granted full legal spousal benefits, equivalent to those of heterosexual Canadians. Be very careful of historical examples, however, since they are almost always complex and inherently ambiguous, there being many different interpretations of what really happened and why.

The final goal of an argument is usually to reach a conclusion which is sufficiently persuasive to convince someone of something a course of action, the reasons for an event, the responsibility for certain acts, the probable truth of an analysis, or the validity of an interpretation.

One word of caution, however: Paragraph goes on to discuss how particular details of this poem illustrate the points she has been making in the previous paragraphs Essay B The opening series of paragraphs discusses important defects in the federal government's strategy in the debates on the Meech Lake Accord These various misjudgments on the part of the Mulroney Conservatives created some embarrassing incidents.

Most of your undergraduate courses spend a good deal of time dealing with induction, instructing you what counts as evidence in a particular discipline, how one sets about collecting and classifying it laboratory or field procedures, methods of reading literatureand what conclusions one is entitled to derive from it.

Similarly, if I argue that Berlin is the capital of Germany and you A handbook on writing argumentative and interpretative essays that I am wrong, because Bonn is the capital, then we can resolve that argument quickly by referring to an acceptable authority on the subject.

There are many useful ways to analyze arguments.

Essays and Arguments: A Handbook for Writing Student Essays

You have made your first and second argumentative points that the system is slow and that it discriminates unfairly against some people. Child abuse is very frequent in modern industrial society. Such a procedure might help to confirm a very enthusiastic response to the text or to point out some of the reasons for our sense of dissatisfaction or puzzlement with the argument.

You can only do this, however, if you give Thinker X a proper chance to deal with the counterexample. The point of the example is not announced until the last line. It is prompted usually by a disagreement, confusion, or ignorance about something which the arguers wish to resolve or illuminate in a convincing way.

In any situation where we begin to abandon our agreement that such decisions will resolve the issue for example, by taking the law into our own hands if the result does not satisfy usthe fabric of society starts to experience important and dangerous tensions.

However, you need at this point to recognize that any argument which starts from a shared assumption about the truth of a general principle is a deductive argument and that the persuasiveness of the argument is going to depend, in large part, on the shared truth of that general principle.

Essays and Arguments: A Handbook for Writing Student Essays

It is asking you only to indicate the form of reasoning used, inductive or deductive. Why does Thinker X make this claim? Johnston combines a lucid introduction to everyday logic with practical advice on composing arguments.

Please turn JavaScript on and reload the page.

While the subject matter will vary from one course to another, in almost all disciplines the major purpose of study is to develop students' ability to read, understand, evaluate, and construct arguments, written and oral. Then the writer moves directly into the introductory paragraph, which announces the subject, focus, and thesis.

The latter is generally a sign that whatever is supposed to be working to resolve disagreements is no longer effective. Appeals to context are often a very important part of very detailed studies of the origins of particular ideas or artistic works, and they can often usefully explicate some things we may find puzzling in the language.

Paragraph goes on in detail to examine one portion of the remarks of one judge Another determining factor in the judgment was the definition of work on the farm. Many student essays, for example, in which an argument is called for set the essay up as asserting something very obvious a matter of fact.

At the same time, remember the point stressed above, that an evaluation is not a summary.

Essays and Arguments: a handbook on Writing Argumentative and Interpretative Essays

We can appreciate this problem clearly by considering another point repeat process d to f. Is it right for me to oppose capital punishment? They are told to remain in line silently until one of them can guess the colour of the hat on his head.

Essays and Arguments: A Handbook on Writing Argumentative

Note that in the above structure you are giving Thinker X a good hearing in at least three respects: Making correct deductions is not always easy, for there are a number of pitfalls we will be looking at some of them later.

However, if the illustration is a good one and you discuss it well, it will bring your argument alive and will enable you to consolidate the points you have already made a particularly important strategy in essays on public issues about which there are strong feelings. Only gradually does one get the sense that there is something odd about the scene.

For instance, suppose you are presenting an argument on the unfairness of the present system of distributing welfare in BC. For example, if I argue that I am taller than you and if you disagree, then we may argue about the fact.

This is a logical process by which we move from something we already all agree to be true to the application of this general truth to a particular case e. Indicate beside each argument whether it is an example of deductive or inductive reasoning you can use the letters D and I.

In other words, instead of giving the reader right at the start of the argument all the background facts he is going to need to understand every part of your argument, you reserve some of the information that you might put in the essay as part of the introduction and insert it where it is first needed.

These are often the most interesting and useful. However, this argument immediately suggests a quick resolution: Child abuse is very frequent in modern industrial society.

This may be polite, or mixed, or strong, or questioning, but it is a personal evaluation, not just a condensed review without evaluation of the argument you are addressing.

Essays and Arguments: a handbook on Writing Argumentative and Interpretative Essays

If you are going to use a narrative or descriptive hook, then make sure you observe the following principles:Structuring an Argument: Coming into Writingmany students will have no idea how to organize an argument paper. Though it's good to give them some flexibility, general guidelines always help.

Though it's good to give them. Essays and Arguments: A Handbook on Writing Argumentative and Interpretative Essays (Revised Edition, May ) by Ian Johnston Malaspina University College. Essays and Arguments: A Handbook on Writing Argumentative and Interpretative Essays (Revised Edition, May ) by Ian Johnston Malaspina University College [This text has been prepared for the use of students in Liberal Studies and English courses at Malaspina University College, Nanaimo, BC.

This text is in the public. скачать Essays and Arguments: A Handbook on Writing Argumentative and Interpretative Essays (Revised Edition, May ) by Ian Johnston Malaspina University College. Essays and Arguments: a handbook on Writing Argumentative and Interpretative Essays Similar The course teaches and requires students to write in.

Essays and Arguments: A Handbook on Writing Argumentative and Interpretative Essays (Revised Edition, May ) By Ian Johnston Malaspina Univer Slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to .

Download
A handbook on writing argumentative and interpretative essays
Rated 3/5 based on 62 review